Calendar of Events Hours & Location Search & Site Map Contact Us
For Students For Employers & Recruiters For Alumni & Alumnae For Faculty & Staff About the Career Center
Home :: For Students :: Services for Graduate Students :: Evaluation Personal and Professional Fit
 

 

Evaluating Personal and Professional Fit

 

   

Participants:

Eileen VanTassell (Michigan State University)
Jeanne Raisler (Nursing)
Naomi Andre (Music)
Alford Young (Sociology, Afroamerican and African Studies)
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Single page
 

Eileen VanTassell (Michigan State University)

My job search started after a postdoc that I decided to do, and in the sciences now you really need to do that. If you’re not in the sciences, you can go right from your undergraduate degree and look for academic positions. Usually though if you want to be a professor in academe, you’d have to go for at least your masters and probably your Ph.D. How many of you are finishing up Ph.D.s here? A number of you are.

I would say that my view of academe was extremely unrealistic when I started out. I thought I was going to find this community of scholars, all of whom were going to help me and be intellectually challenging and ready to debate all kinds of unusual and different issues, and what I found was that people are people. And you will find a few of those, but for the most part a Ph.D. does not give you any special human curiosities or skills that you wouldn’t find in your grandmother’s house or down the street somewhere in your own neighborhood. I really had to learn that I had to seek out those individuals. So I was very unrealistic about that. I got myself into a lot of trouble as a result, right off the bat.

I think it’s really important that if you take a job in any kind of high stress situation that you make time for yourself and that you don’t give up your own hobbies, so that you don’t sacrifice too much of yourself because you have to stay strong. And in order to stay strong and be able to give of yourself, you have to be able to give to yourself, too. And so I think you can get really burned out in an academic situation or even a nonacademic situation where there’s job stress when you’re first starting out, there’s bound to be. So what I do is I participate in martial arts; I participate in the Native American community, and I love gardening. And I try to do some of those on an ongoing basis, just to keep myself healthy.

My priorities are my family first, then my job, then my hobbies. And I think the family and job come into conflict often. And every person has to decide for themselves, based on the situation, just how far they can push that job envelope with respect to their other priorities. So, I think anything I said about that would be a little dangerous, but there are going to be colleagues and mentors that you can always call on. And I recommend that you do not use individuals in your current department – or the department that you find yourself in or the unit that you find yourself in if you’re not in academe – but that you seek out values mentors where you are now. And I would suggest that you keep close ties with those individuals that you trust and that you seek advice like that from them, because you can’t tell always what the values are of the people that you’re meeting for the first time and you may offend someone without even knowing it. So, I recommend that you give yourself lots of time in a new position to find mentors that you trust, and that may take a year or two or even three years to do that.

With respect to interviewing, I would not bring up the issue of a spouse. And the main reason is because I’m not currently married, so it would be inappropriate, but – it would be dishonest, I could of course make one up but that’s frowned upon – what I think works well is that you let your employer know that you are happy in the relationship that you’re in and there are many, many ways of doing that without going out of your way to bring up your relationships, which I don’t think you need to do. But you could say things to the effect that “While I’ve been married or in my current relationship for 5 years and I’m really lucky to have found such a supportive person.” Having a supportive spouse is very important often to employers, such that you are a stable person that is going to have the kind of home support that will allow you to do the job that you’ve been hired to do. If you are in a very stormy or difficult situation, your employer may feel that you may not be able to handle the position. Same thing with children. You may have listed how many children you have on your resume. It’s not really legal for anyone to ask you specifically about your spouse or your children, but you are free to bring up good and happy things about your spouse or your children. Never bellyache about it, I would say. Don’t reveal negative things about how difficult you’re finding childcare and so forth and so on. That’s not a good idea.

With respect to evaluating the community, I don’t think there’s any really good way to do this except by asking potential friends that you may have at or near that area, or perhaps people here at UM who have been at the place where you’re planning to go. So do some background work on that. Then I would say check out some of the local newspapers and community magazines when you get there for that kind of information.

With respect to evaluating the place that you’re going to be – or where you’re thinking about being – I would say that you can usually tell whether the people you meet are happy. And that’s very, very important. If people seem to be happy, if they seem to be somewhat relaxed but with – I would say – a nice professional tension, and you probably know what I mean by that. So that they’re not so laid back that you can tell that nobody’s getting anything done here, but they’re not so tense and driven that you can see right away that unless you publish ten papers right away in your first year you’re not going to make it. So you want to find a kind of a balance there. So it’s important to find out in an academic situation whether the people in your unit are productive, and that’s easy to do. You can ask people that you meet for their recent papers, and that’s perfectly acceptable. If they don’t have any, that’s perhaps a warning sign. Or if you’re looking for a position in a teaching institution where research is not so demanding or your productivity is less important than perhaps your classroom, you might ask people about their classes and what kind of students they encounter there, as a way to talk about things. It’s always a good idea to meet students while you’re there, if you’re on a campus, or to talk to ordinary working people at any kind of job situation you’re at. So, if you go into the cafeteria, you can talk to people about what kind of place it is, and see what people have to say.

Is the leadership of your institution fairly stable? I think that’s important to look at. Or is the dean changing every couple of years or the president changing every couple of years or your department chair. And you also want to look at what the benefits are apart from salary. For instance, what is their retirement program like? What is the community like with respect to such things as provision for your recreational needs? Do they have an athletic program that you can participate in? Or whatever your interest is? Can that be met in this community that you’re going into? Also, does the institution invest in the appropriate resources to support you in the job that you’re going to be doing? At my institution, that would mean a world class library, and I would insist upon that and never go anywhere that didn’t have a world class library. Although nowadays with e-mail and being able to download all your resources at the click of a key, it’s less problematic. But still I would say if you’re at an institution that your not etherneted so you can’t get at those resources, you could be in a difficult situation. So, think about that. Think about what resources you need and make sure that the place you’re interviewing has that and can meet your needs. And then if appropriate, what are the institution’s provisions for daycare or plans for daycare if you intend or already have a family, and I think I’ll stop there.

 

| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Single page

 

PhDs and the Academic Job Search

 

The Career Center